Categorized | Albums

Midlake – The Courage of Others

Now when I first got asked to review this CD, I went and checked ’s MySpace out and I can’t lie, I was just a bit scared about how it was going to sound. Everything on their MySpace gave me this sick feeling in my stomach and made me want to roll my eyes. The vocals were all beautiful. I loved that and I think acoustically all of the songs would have sounded amazing, but what was up had all of these background noises (it was a lot of obvious fake sounds mixed with very little actual guitar or drums or anything else that I would consider ‘real’) that just screamed we’re just trying to be a pretentious indie band. It wasn’t that it was absolutely horrible it was just too much for my poor stomach to handle, but hey some people like that sort of stuff, and if that’s your bag, that’s your bag, I won’t judge you. midlake

Now as skeptical as I was before I even got the CD, I swore I would at least give it a chance. A chance I do have to say that it at the very least earned. I turned it on (metaphorically of course, after all you don’t really turn on iTunes, and really, who uses anything but iTunes anymore?) and was actually quite surprised. I expected more eye-rolling indie music but what I got was much, much more folky. While there are some remnants of the rest it is much less blatant, enough of an undertone on the record to be tolerable. It went from something you’d expect your run of the mill pretentious hipster to listen to something much more pleasing on the ears. It’s the sort of thing I’d want to listen to if I was walking through a forest alone or just needed to calm down and hang out in my apartment in the dark and relax. It did give me an almost amusing feeling like I should be watching the movie Robin Hood. It has a very old world guitar feeling to it in the background that reminded me just of how lutes sound in many old period pieces.

There were a few songs that still made me roll my eyes a little with their intros, but for the most part if you could get past the first 15 seconds, it was all good. This CD isn’t necessarily something I’d go out of my way to listen to, but I wouldn’t skip past it if it came up on shuffle on my iPod either. I’d recommend at least giving the CD a try if you’re into more folky. There’d certainly be no harm in it.

Track Listing:

  1. Acts Of Man
  2. Winter Dies
  3. Small Mountain
  4. Core Of Nature
  5. Fortune
  6. Rulers, Ruling All Things
  7. Children Of The Grounds
  8. Bring Down
  9. The Horn
  10. The Courage Of Others
  11. In The Ground

Written by Hanna Marie Pageau

Related Posts

This post was written by:

- who has written 1186 posts on popwreckoning.

I'm a rocker, I rock out.

Contact the author

  • http://n/a David

    I’m curious as to what bands you go out of your way to hear?

  • http://www.myspace.com/hotterthanjuly Michael

    It’s quite a shame that this “review” says little about the album itself.

  • sam

    didi you get paid to write that?

  • http://eh erik garant

    Sorry, but really, were you trying to be bad at reviewing music?
    you should change careers, or at the very least apologize to the people that read this. i’m not trying to be a jerk, but really, any music fan would agree with me when i say that this is just some complaining and some weird attitude that is seemingly based on a group of people [indie rockers you roll your eyes at] that you don’t like.
    you did not reference any other artists (bands, singer song writers) or give the reader any hint to what the feeling is of what you heard.

    I’m guessing that you must listen to a popular, budweiser funded radio station that has “block party weekends” and “gets the led out”, which is all fine and grand, but for the sake of music and the people that appreciate, please,please,please STICK TO WHAT YOU KNOW.
    If you cannot take time to LISTEN and have a decent and music-knowledgeable opinion … please.

    Thanks and have a great block party weekend!
    Erik

  • Frankenhooker

    Jesus wept. The sum of your ‘review’ is you wouldn’t turn it off if it popped up on shuffle ? You actually need to listen to Midlake (or any album for that matter) before making a judgement and at least keep an open mind.

    For what it’s worth, if anyone actually seeks this site out for a review, the album is stunning. It’s probably one of the most beautiful albums I’ve listened to in the past five years. The ‘Eagles’ comparisons are probably still apt but honesty, experience and direction are the first things I got out of this album.

  • tim

    apparently there’s new sex and the city movie being released…maybe you should review that..think it might be more your calibre

  • Tyler

    This review is absolute garbage, it sounds like someone’s myspace blog entry. This is what happens when you find unpaid writers on Craigslist. Yet somehow this site looks legit and has a few advertisers. This is really, really bad. Was the writer of this review in high school? Was this edited? How did this run? My god.

  • KnowsGuy

    Hey, Hanna.

    You are a terrible critic. You make me roll my eyes.

  • focus

    That was pretty bad

  • sadderthanowlsongs

    That was the worst review I have ever read. You give no insight and have no knowledge of the band or the genre. This is just plain lazy.

Like us!

Advertise with PopWreck!

To keep this site up and running, we reserve the sidebar for ads. In that case, put your ad here. All that's needed is for you to fill out this lovely form.

disclaimer

All media content contained within PopWreckoning is meant to enhance reader appreciation for the art and medium. Please support artists you discover here by purchasing albums, attending shows and buying merch.
Contact us should you wish for certain media to be removed from PopWreckoning.

Concert Calendar

Nov 23, 2011
HaHa Tonka @ Recordbar, Kansas City MO

Nov 25, 2011
Thee Oh Sees @ The Granada, Lawrence KS

Nov 25, 2011
Baby Teardrops - Vinyl Release @ The Brick, Kansas City MO

Dec 1, 2011 Now, Now @ Recordbar, Kansas City MO

Dec 9, 2011 Felix Culpa - Farewell Show @ The Metro, Chicago IL
"PopWreckoning is better than Pitchfork." - Shawn Fogel

PopWreckers

Publisher ::
Nick Davis (Kansas City)

Editor-in-Chief ::
Joshua Hammond (Kansas City): email

Music Editor ::
Casey Osburn (Kansas City)

Literature Editor ::
Devon Mueller (Columbia, Mo)

Movie Editor ::
David Womeldorff (Kansas City)

Music Contributors ::
Mary Chang (DC)
Melissa Cowan (Kansas City)
Jeffrey Whitelaw (Kansas City)

Staff Photographers ::
Todd Zimmer (Kansas City) Scott Spychalski (Kansas City)

Music Submissions ::
Music Contact

Movie Submissions ::
Movies Contact

Literature Submissions ::
Literature Contact

Comics Submissions ::
Comic Book Contact

Television Submissions ::
Television Contact