As I’m nearing my 21st birthday, the ever-present anxiety surrounding who’s playing all ages shows has gone out the door. However, the last all-ages show I will see as a 20-year-old human being (well, except for Sasquatch this weekend) turned out to be Broken Bells and The Morning Benders at the Showbox this week.
This is the first time I’ve seen a band since…February… that I was almost more excited to see the opening band than the actual headliners. Nothing against Broken Bells – their debut album is fantastic, but having seen The Morning Benders two times prior, first with We Are Scientists in 2008 and then with Grizzly Bear last October, I was really looking forward to seeing them for a third time.
The Showbox was packed. Packed tight light a space bag, but instead of blankets and pillows, it was full of people. Starting at about 9, the Berkeley natives stepped out on stage – Chris Chu on lead vocals, Tim Orr on bass, John Chu on guitar and keyboards, and Julian Harmon on drums. The one thing that I always loved about seeing these guys live is how humble they are. Each time they thank the headliners multiple times and thank the crowd for “coming early to see us.” I may have said this before, but I didn’t go early, I went on time! It was also nice to see that Chris’ brother John, who joined the band last year, was sporting the same Telecaster that Chris used two years ago, with the familiar “Britney Spears” label, even if it was quasi-covered in duct tape.
They started with “Stitches,” an achingly beautiful ballad that builds to an ending no less than epic with the lyric “you don’t know me by name” repeated over and over; and it was also my second-favorite song off their phenomenal second album Big Echo. The guys were much more at ease on stage than when I saw them in October, when prior to the show someone broke into their van and stole a bunch of their equipment. At this gig, they were fully equipped with not only their instruments, but so many of the great songs off Big Echo, including the slower “Wet Cement” and “Mason Jar,” along with more upbeat tracks like “Promises,”
“All Day All Night” and the short ditty “Cold War (Nice Clean Fight).”
Throughout their performance I glanced around where I was standing, and I was the only person singing along to virtually every song. No, really. Thankfully they closed with “Excuses,” as people had been shouting it various times up until then, so people had to sing along. Chris put down his guitar and grabbed the mic off the stand, and came to find that it was going to cut in and out, so he scrapped his mic and grabbed John’s from atop his keyboard. In the absence of the strings, John played the chords on his keyboard while Chris meandered around the stage from the right side to the left, singing the lovely song directly to the audience. I swear, when I heard “Excuses” for the first time, I thought I’m playing this song at my wedding, whenever it may be. It’s that adorable, but somehow not saccharine. At this point I urged everyone around me to sing along to the “da dum, da dum, la da da dum,” and I finally wasn’t the only one joining in the song.
After a half-hour intermission, Broken Bells, led by James Mercer, stepped out on stage to an ecstatic crowd. I mean, the crowd had to be ecstatic – the show sold out in a matter of days when the tickets went on sale a couple of months ago. Before jumping right into “Vaporize,” James Mercer declared to the audience, “you’re too good to me, Seattle.” To tell you the truth, we’re pretty good to most people.
Broken Bells played through the light and fun songs off their self-titled debut, as well as a cover of Tommy James and the Shondells’ “Crimson & Clover” that was pretty ace. I’d have to say that their set wasn’t quite as dynamic as the Morning Benders, but it was far from boring.
I like Broken Bells music because you can dance to it, but it’s so slow that it turns into a slow dance and it’s not so fast that you get tired when you’re dancing for almost an hour.
I especially liked when Brian Burton (better known as Danger Mouse) got up from the drums and sat at the keyboard in the middle of the stage, which was otherwise vacant without Burton playing. I never really knew how multi-talented he is. Burton surely has an impressive resume.
The only thing that spoiled my night was the fact that halfway through Broken Bells’ set this guy who was obviously high on something (something that apparently makes you a total and complete butthead) came and stood right next to me and started thrusting himself around obnoxiously like he was in a mosh pit. Okay, so Broken Bells isn’t mellow, but they aren’t necessarily mosh-able. He even suggested at one point while he was filming the show with his phone that he was going to crowd surf, before the guy standing behind him told him off. Honestly if that guy had crowd-surfed, I would have let him drop.
I know personal space technically goes out the window when you’re at a show, but when no one else around you is gnashing against one another, you should take a hint that you need to chill.
Trying to ignore the annoying dude standing next to me, I joined in the crowd’s massive sing-along to “Crimson & Clover,” which would have been a nice surprise if I hadn’t taken a picture of the set list before Broken Bells came onstage. It was still quite nice, though.
After their first “last” song, Mercer and Burton played a charming version of “Insane Lullaby,” from Danger Mouse and Sparklehorse’s 2009 album Dark Night of the Soul. You don’t normally expect two covers in one show, and this was pretty cool. It was just Mercer on acoustic guitar and Burton on keyboards, and it worked really well. They finished out the night with my favorite song from the album, “October,” which instantly made the crowd sway to-and-fro to the easy beat, and the dude standing next to me finally calmed down.
Broken Bells Set List:
- Vaporize
- Sailing to Nowhere
- Trap Doors
- Citizen
- High Road
- Your Head is On Fire
- The Ghost Inside
- Crimson & Clover
- Mongrel Heart
- The Mall and the Misery
Encore
- Insane Lullaby
- Hold On
- October











































